| 21st Century | 1-866-342-2045 | | | 5 | | | |
| AAA | 1-800-779-5630 | 1 year to file | pre-supp decking | 5 | Matching Exclusions, need 535 endorsement. Local adjusters suck, CAT adusters good | | |
| AIG | 1-888-760-9195 | | pre-supplement | 10 | VERY GOOD | | |
| Acuity | 1-800-242-7666 | | pre-supplement | 6.5 | Matching exclusions, matching caps, metal marring exclusions | | |
| American Family | 1-800-692-6326 | 1 year to file and have repairs completed* | pre-supplement | 6 | Matching Exclusions, need 535 endorsement. Metal marring exclusion | | - RPS = Roof 10 years +, |
| American National | 1-800-333-2860 | | | 4 | Code Upgrade Cap. | | |
| Ameriprise (now Connect by Amfam) | 1-800-872-5246 | | | 6 | ACV only and/or high deductibles can be common on these policies | | |
| American Modern | 1-800-375-2075 | | | 4 | Slow. | | |
| American Reliable | 1-800-245-1505 | | | 5 | | | |
| Amica | 1-800-242-6422 | | | 6 | | | |
| Allied | 1-800-282-1446 | | | 5 | | | |
| Allstate | 1-800-255-7828 | 1 year to file | pre-supp decking | 5 | Some have "RPS" Policies - (roof surface payment schedule - which is basically like non recoverable depreciation) | | |
| ASI | 1-866-274-5677 | 1 year to file | | 5 | Matching cap, typically will pay up to 2% of the home value to match undamaged material | | |
| Austin Mutual | 1-800-328-4628 | | | 5 | | | |
| Auto Owners | 1-888-252-4626 | 1 year to file | | 6 | Claims supposed to be filed through agent, but can call the after hours number listed here. | | - Matching Caps |
| Badger Mutual | 1-800-837-7833 | | | 5 | Some policies may excluide matching coverage, Decent with approving, lower on pricing | | |
| Cincinnati | 1-877-242-2544 | | pre-supplement | 8 | RPS Policies | RPS | |
| Chubb | 1-800-252-4670 | 2 years | pre-supplement | 10 | Extremely good - high end insurance - one of the best | | |
| Country FInancial | 1-866-268-6879 | | | 5 | Code Coverage, ACV after 10 years, | | |
| Electric Insurance | 800-227-2757 | | | 7 | | | |
| EMC Insurance | 1-888-362-2255 | | | 5 | | | |
| Encompass | 1-800-588-7400 | | pre-supplement | 4 | Want 13 hits per test square, adjuster Mark Callen kinda sucks | | |
| Farm Bureau | 1-877-876-2222 | | pre-supplement | 5 | | | |
| Farmers Insurance | 1-800-435-7764 | 1 Year to file | pre-supp siding | 6.5 | Most policies exclude matching, unless client has 535 Matching endorsement, may exclude damage to soft metal (metal marring exclusion); Matching Cap 10-30K | | |
| Federated | 1-888-333-4949 | | | 6.5 | | | |
| Firemans Fund | 1-(888) 347-3428 | | | 6 | | | |
| Foremost | | 1 Year to file | | 6 | ACV Only, | | No Matching. Roofs over 15 years use "Partial Loss Payment Method" - ACV only 15 years and older |
| Integrity Insurance | 1-800-445-3030 | | | 6 | | | |
| Harleysville | 1-800-892-8877 | | | 5 | | | |
| Hartford | 1-800-243-5860 | | | 5 | | | |
| Homesite (progressive) | 1-866-960-8609 | 1 year to file | | 5 | They usually cap the allowance for undamaged items paid for on matching - (often the cap is 2% of home value) | | 1% Deductible, |
| Horace Mann | 1-800-999-1030 | | pre-supplement | 5 | ACV Only Roof | | |
| Kemper | 1-888-252-2799 | | | 5 | | | |
| Liberty Mutual | 1-800-225-2467 | 1 year to file | pre-supplement | 5 | Roof = ACV 10+ years; Matching Cap, | | |
| Nationwide | 1-800-421-3535 | | pre-supplement | 7 | | | |
| Northstar Mutual | 1-800-622-5230 | | | 1 | Terrible, dont approve and they use low fixed pricing, usually unbuildable | | |
| Pharmacists Insurance | 1-800-247-5930 | | | 8 | Very rare, but very good | | |
| Penn National | | | | | | | |
| Pure | 1-888-813-7873 | | | 8.5 | RPS Policies | RPS Policy | RPS Policy |
| Ram | 1-800-727-1315 | | | 5 | | | |
| Safeco (now owned by Lib Mutual) | 1-800-332-3226 | 1 year to file | pre-supplement | 5 | Roof = ACV 10+ years; Matching Cap, Ordinance or Law Cap | | |
| Secura | 1-800-318-2136 | | | 7 | May have a matching cap of $20k for undamaged items depending on policy, pretty good company. | Not in Market | Not in Market |
| Selective | 1-866-455-9969 | | pre-supplement | 5 | | | |
| Sentry | 1-800-325-9559 | | | 5 | | | |
| State Auto | 1-800-766-1853 | | | 5 | Roof Marketplace Bids, | | |
| State Farm | 1-800-732-5246 | 2 years | | 5 | Biggest company - they have 1/3 of market share. | | |
| Travelers | 1-800-252-4633 | 2 years | | 4 | | | Metal Exclusions, No Matching, RPS |
| Universal Insurance | 1-800-470-0599 | | pre-supplement | 5 | ACV Roof = 10 + years old, Matching Exclusions. | | |
| USAA | 210-531-8722 | 2 years | | 8 | No Matching - Roof; 18 Months after initial ACV payment to complete the work | | |
| West Bend | 1-877-922-5246 | | pre-supplement | 4 | Will approve but lower price per square - usually 550-650 max, slow to process supplement | | |
| Western National | 1-855-921-3164 | 1 Year to File | pre-supplement | 7 | Roof may be ACV only if over 10 years old | | 1% Cov A Deductible, Matching Cap, Code Coverage up to 10% of Cov A, Metal Exclusion (Roofing), |
| Wilson Mutual | 1-800-242-7708 | | | 5 | | | |
| Westfield | 800-243-0210 | | | 7.5 | Some policies may have Cosmetic exclusions on metal damage | Cosmetic Metal Exclusion - Roofing | No Matching, Cosmetic Metal Exclusion on entire exterior. |
| QBE | 1-800-822-2997 | | pre-supplement | 6 | ACv Only | | |